• Home
  • Bank of Subjects of Articles
    • Bibliography
    • Characters
    • Culture and art
    • Economics
    • Educational sciences
    • ethics
    • Geography of Islamic world
    • History
    • Islamic jurisprudence and principles
    • Kalam (Islamic scholastic theology)
    • Mahdism
    • Philosophy and logic
    • Political science
    • pray and pilgrimage
    • Prophet and Ahl-al bayt
  • Islamic Teachings
  • quran
  • The Infallibles
  • Shia Beliefs
  • Morality
  • Events
    • Media Reflection
    • Muharram
    • News of Shia World
    • News of Worldly Assembly for Shia Studies
  • Home
  • Bank of Subjects of Articles
    • Bibliography
    • Characters
    • Culture and art
    • Economics
    • Educational sciences
    • ethics
    • Geography of Islamic world
    • History
    • Islamic jurisprudence and principles
    • Kalam (Islamic scholastic theology)
    • Mahdism
    • Philosophy and logic
    • Political science
    • pray and pilgrimage
    • Prophet and Ahl-al bayt
  • Islamic Teachings
  • quran
  • The Infallibles
  • Shia Beliefs
  • Morality
  • Events
    • Media Reflection
    • Muharram
    • News of Shia World
    • News of Worldly Assembly for Shia Studies
Home exegises

what the theologians, the philosophers, the Sufis and the people of tradition say about the exegesis of the Quran?

by javad
2020-10-21
in exegises, quran
0
what the theologians, the philosophers, the Sufis and the people of tradition say about the exegesis of the Quran?
0
SHARES
32
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The theologians’ lot was worse all the more. They were divided into myriads of sects; and each group clung to the verse that seemed to support its belief and tried to explain away what was apparently against it. The seed of sectarian differences was sown in academic theories or, more often than not, in blind following and national or tribal prejudice; but it is not the place to describe it even briefly. However, such exegesis should be called adaptation, rather than explanation. There are two ways of explaining a verse — One may say: “What does the Qur’ãn say?” Or one may say: “How can this verse be explained, so as to fit on my belief?”

The difference between the two approaches is quite clear. The former forgets every pre-conceived idea and goes where the Qur’ãn leads him to. The latter has already decided what to believe and cuts the Qur’ãnic verses to fit on that body; such an exegesis is no exegesis at all. The philosophers too suffered from the same syndrome. They tried to fit the verses on the principles of Greek philosophy (that was divided into four branches: Mathematics, natural science, divinity and practical subjects including civics). If a verse was clearly against those principles it was explained away.

In this way the verses describing metaphysical subjects, those explaining the genesis and creation of the heavens and the earth, those concerned with life after death and those about resurrection, paradise and hell were distorted to conform with the said philosophy. That philosophy was admittedly only a set of conjectures — unencumbered with any test or proof; but the Muslim philosophers felt no remorse in treating its views on the system of skies, orbits, natural elements and other related subjects as the absolute truth with which the exegesis of the Qur’ãn had to conform.

Tags: exegisesphilosophersQuranshaistudiestheologians
Previous Post

what the theologians, the philosophers, the Sufis and the people of tradition say about the exegesis of the Quran?

Next Post

what the theologians, the philosophers, the Sufis and the people of tradition say about the exegesis of the Quran?

javad

Related Posts

commentary of one verse of the Glorious Qur'an
quran

Commentary Of One Verse Of The Glorious Qur’an part25

by شهاب الدین مجتهدی
2024-04-06
commentary of one verse of the Glorious Qur'an
quran

Commentary Of One Verse Of The Glorious Qur’an part24

by شهاب الدین مجتهدی
2024-04-06
commentary of one verse of the Glorious Qur'an
quran

Commentary Of One Verse Of The Glorious Qur’an par23

by شهاب الدین مجتهدی
2024-04-06
commentary of one verse of the Glorious Qur'an
quran

Commentary Of One Verse Of The Glorious Qur’an part22

by شهاب الدین مجتهدی
2024-04-06
commentary of one verse of the Glorious Qur'an
quran

Commentary Of One Verse Of The Glorious Qur’an part21

by شهاب الدین مجتهدی
2024-04-06
Next Post
what the theologians, the philosophers, the Sufis and the people of tradition say about the exegesis of the Quran?

what the theologians, the philosophers, the Sufis and the people of tradition say about the exegesis of the Quran?

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Post

Ayat Peyman, Secretary-General of the World Assembly of Shiite Studies: “America’s Prestige Has Crumbled Around the World”   vista.ir

Ayat Peyman, Secretary-General of the World Assembly of Shiite Studies: “America’s Prestige Has Crumbled Around the World” vista.ir

2026-10-18
The Supreme Leader’s Message on the Occasion of the Birth Anniversary of Lady Zaynab (peace be upon her) and Nurses’ Day Nurses: Reviving Life and Inspiring Hope in Society

The Supreme Leader’s Message on the Occasion of the Birth Anniversary of Lady Zaynab (peace be upon her) and Nurses’ Day Nurses: Reviving Life and Inspiring Hope in Society

2026-10-18
Al-Sahifa al-Sajjadiyya: The Psalms of the Household of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)

Al-Sahifa al-Sajjadiyya: The Psalms of the Household of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)

2026-10-13
An Introduction to Shi‘a Studies: A Review of the Book

An Introduction to Shi‘a Studies: A Review of the Book

2026-10-10
The Imam: A Revealed Truth from the Unseen Realm

The Imam: A Revealed Truth from the Unseen Realm

2026-10-04
I Want to Support the Shia School of Thought

I Want to Support the Shia School of Thought

2026-10-01
Load More

Browse by Tags

Ahl al-Bayt (A.S.) Ahlul Bayt Al-Mahdi (AS) Allah Ashura Ayatollah Sobhani Ethics faith Fatima fiqh ghadir God History Holy Prophet Imam 'Ali Imam Ali (A.S.) Imam Husain Imams infallibles Islam Islamic Laws Islamic rules Jurisprudence Karbala Martyrdom morality Muhammad Nahj al Balaghah prayer prophet Quran Ramadan Reborn Salat Sayed Moustafa Qazwini shaistudies shia Shia Beliefs Shia Imams Shia Islam Shia Studie's World Assembly shiastudies Sin the differences between Shi’a and Sunni the story of those who converted to Shia Islam

The World Assembly of Shiite Studies was established in 2003 (1382 AH) by a group of scholars from seminaries and universities. The purpose of founding this independent academic institution was to introduce the school of Shi‘ism and defend its legitimacy through education, research, translation and publication, communications, and Islamic promotion. This center has continued its mission with strength and determination and envisions a bright future ahead.

Address: Qom, 45-Meter Ammar Yaser Boulevard, between Alley 4 and 6, World Assembly of Shiite Studies, Secretariat of Religious Scholars

Phone: +982537713773

Fax: +982537713774

All rights of the website are reserved and belong to the World Assembly of Shiite Studies.